Plectis

Corpus orientation

Technical orientation

Rendered from docs/ORIENTATION.md in the public Lean repository. View source

All sections

Corpus orientation

This is the bounded first-read map for the public release. It is a navigation projection, not proof authority. The published Lean source checked by the pinned Lean kernel remains proof authority.

Release provenance

This checkout is a deliberately curated, independently verifiable public output of a larger ongoing formal-mathematics workflow. No public claim depends on private or unreleased work.

Public evidence of that release workflow: pinned formal-source identity; claim and open-proposition registry; machine-readable argument and module graphs; generated declaration atlas; bounded cold-clone and adversarial checks.

The workflow provenance explains the release discipline; it does not imply hidden proof authority or equivalence with private work.

Mathematical signal first

This is Palomar’s canonical candidate_ranking order, joined to the source declaration and exact boundary in the external-verification packet. It is a reader-priority signal, not a proof, novelty, or problem-closure claim; every ranked family remains reachable below.

Rank Family / status
1 finite_prime_weighted_support / selected
2 known_irrational_supports / represented
3 pairwise_coprime_support / represented
4 orthogonal_petal_sunflower_reduction / represented
5 periodic_nonnegative_weight_irrationality / represented
6 actual_lcm_orbit_separation / represented
7 first_harmonic_pivot_decomposition / represented
8 strict_prime_tail_orbit_gap / represented
9 factorial_carry_characterisation / subordinate
10 prime_gap_reformulation / subordinate
11 totient_carry_anti_compression / represented
12 half_membership_seam_classification / represented
13 negative_mass_recovery / represented

Interface, source declaration, and exact boundary, by rank:

  1. finite_prime_weighted_support Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.divisibilityWeightedClaim → ErdosProblems.Erdos257.PaperCompleteR8.divisibilityWeightedClaim The finite-prime weighted-summability premise is explicit in both clauses. This criterion does not cover every infinite support or settle universal Erdős #257; no novelty, priority, significance, or external human-review claim is made.
  2. known_irrational_supports Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_erdosSum_full_support → Erdos249257.irrational_erdosSum_full_support This is the classical full-support theorem, not universal Erdos #257.
  3. pairwise_coprime_support Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_erdosSupportSeries_pairwise_coprime → Erdos249257.irrational_erdosSupportSeries_pairwise_coprime This is the pairwise-coprime support theorem, not universal Erdos #257; the infinitude, pairwise-coprimality, and summable-reciprocal hypotheses remain explicit.
  4. orthogonal_petal_sunflower_reduction Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_erdosSupportSeries_of_orthogonalPetalBouquet → Erdos249257.SupportSunflowerDichotomy.irrational_erdosSupportSeries_of_orthogonalPetalBouquet This is a conditional reduction: the bouquet structure and uniform tail-selection predicate remain hypotheses; neither is constructed for arbitrary supports, so this does not add an unconditional Erdos #257 support family or solve the universal problem.
  5. periodic_nonnegative_weight_irrationality Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_ratWeightSeries_eventuallyPeriodic → Erdos249257.irrational_ratWeightSeries_eventuallyPeriodic This is the nonnegative rational eventually-periodic coefficient theorem; its nonnegativity, eventual periodicity, and positive-tail hypotheses remain explicit, and the broader mixed-sign periodic theorem is not claimed.
  6. actual_lcm_orbit_separation Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_totientSeries_of_actualLcmOrbitSeparationSupply → Erdos249257.DiagonalFreshLossBridge.PowerTwoOddWindowAffine.irrational_totientSeries_of_actualLcmOrbitSeparationSupply The cofinal separation supply is an open premise, stronger than mere non-integrality; this sufficient route is not an equivalence and leaves the punctured/top-edge boundary and the Erdős #249 endpoint open.
  7. first_harmonic_pivot_decomposition Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_totient_series_of_pivotResidualDecorrelation → Erdos249257.TotientTailPeriodKiller.irrational_totient_series_of_pivotResidualDecorrelation The four-term decomposition and 9X/10 gap remain conditional on the explicit dyadic-room and PivotBudgetAt hypotheses; the cofinal decorrelation producer is unproved. The fibre/image lemmas do not give global supplier-prime isolation or a prime-distribution estimate, and no Erdős #249 irrationality conclusion is claimed.
  8. strict_prime_tail_orbit_gap Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_totient_series_of_naturalPrimeTailOrbitStrictGap → ErdosProblems.Erdos249.irrational_totient_series_of_naturalPrimeTailOrbitStrictGap The phase-density, cofinal natural-prime strict-gap, associated uniform-margin, and cofinal nonpositive-prime-shift producers remain unproved for the actual totient orbit. Exact phase/integrality equivalence, finite dyadic-root exclusion for 1 ≤ h ≤ 16 and k ≤ 14, and non-dyadicity-to-cofinal-nonpositive-phase implications are classification or finite evidence only; they do not supply density or prime alignment, and the source does not prove actual root entry. This is a conditional reduction only: no unconditional Erdős #249 endpoint, novelty, priority, significance, or external-review claim is made. It is distinct from the finite first_harmonic_pivot_decomposition and actual_lcm_orbit_separation families.
  9. factorial_carry_characterisation Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_factorialGapSeries_iff_cofinal_nonunit_carries → ErdosProblems.Erdos68.irrational_factorialGapSeries_iff_cofinal_nonunit_carries The equivalence does not supply a cofinal carry producer.
  10. prime_gap_reformulation Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.irrational_tsum_primeDyadicTerm_iff_primeGap → ErdosProblems.Erdos251.irrational_tsum_primeDyadicTerm_iff_primeGap The equivalence does not prove irrationality of either series.
  11. totient_carry_anti_compression Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.not_irrational_totientSeries_implies_mod_period_and_unbounded_rank → Erdos249257.not_irrational_totientSeries_implies_mod_period_and_unbounded_rank This is a necessary consequence of rationality only: it gives no contradiction, no finite-rank upper bound for a rationality-supplied carry, and no irrationality proof for Erdős #249. Modulo a divisor of the multiplier, the forcing disappears and the carry becomes geometric, so quotient periodicity alone supplies no finite-ℚ-rank upper bound. The coefficient-side kernel-rank and certificate-equivalence families are not duplicated, and #249 remains open.
  12. half_membership_seam_classification Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.half_mem_mersenneAchievementSet_iff_unboundedTerminalFalse → Erdos249257.half_mem_mersenneAchievementSet_iff_unboundedTerminalFalse This exact endpoint-socket classification does not supply any unbounded terminal-false or upper-or-middle occurrences, cofinal supply, skipped-support producer, or half-membership witness; finite exact rows do not establish the required global supply. It is not an unconditional or universal Erdős #257 result, and no novelty, priority, significance, or external-review claim is made.
  13. negative_mass_recovery Erdos249257.ExternalVerification.sylvesterNext_eventually_of_summable_negativeRelativeMass → ErdosProblems.Erdos243.sylvesterNext_eventually_of_summable_negativeRelativeMass This is a conditional recovery criterion: the source theorem assumes every displayed dynamics, positivity, strict centered-step, normalized-vanishing, and summability hypothesis, and does not prove them for the original Erdős #243 orbit. Any surviving canonical orbit must have divergent normalized negative mass. It supplies no prime-specific producer, unconditional #243 endpoint, or reciprocal-tail irrationality, and makes no novelty, priority, significance, or external-review claim. It is distinct from centered_state_dynamics, which uses a uniform lower-bound hypothesis rather than summability of normalized negative mass.

Reader tiers and relational boundaries

Palomar’s presentation tiers are the reader routing contract (not a second rank or proof-status authority): source-ranked frontier → conditional endpoint leverage → deep mechanism and classification → natural friction and no-go → supporting and long tail

Exact family-to-tier placements, open producers, and contrary evidence remain in docs/orientation.json under the same Palomar authority.

What a claim status asserts

A status states the exact public evidence claim, not a priority or novelty claim. The prior-art record, not this table, supplies antecedents.

Status Exact public meaning
proved here Lean theorem in the committed formal-source checkpoint; no novelty assertion is implied
formalised here Known mathematics represented and checked in Lean
unconditional progress Genuine theorem that does not settle the open problem
conditional reduction Exact implication whose remaining hypothesis is open
verified finite instance Kernel-checked computation at a bounded range
cited only External theorem used for positioning, not formalised
open Not proved by this release
formal statement refuted Lean refutes the exact Formal Conjectures statement; correspondence with the original wording awaits independent review

Exact open boundary

  • remaining_open.erdos_68_irrationality — Prove that S = ∑_{n≥2} 1/(n! − 1) is irrational.
  • remaining_open.erdos_249_irrationality — Prove that S = ∑ φ(n)/2ⁿ is irrational, with no bound on a possible rational denominator.
  • remaining_open.erdos_251_irrationality — Prove that Π = ∑_{n≥1} p_n/2ⁿ is irrational; the exact tail-shift equivalence and prime-gap constraints do not supply the required cofinal escape.
  • remaining_open.unbounded_certificate_supply — Produce certified non-integrality witnesses at unbounded parameters. A sufficient one-parameter form is to produce them along the lcm diagonal.
  • remaining_open.half_value_membership — Decide whether 1/2 lies in the Mersenne achievement set. Yes refutes universal #257; no closes only this route.
  • remaining_open.twenty_one_permanent_affine_supercapacity — Decide the exact 1/21 branch: equivalently, exclude the fatal/cofinite/aligned branch, contradict its eventual permanent affine-supercapacity recurrence, prove cofinally bounded scaled greedy remainders, or force an unbounded sequence of closed canonical quotient rows. A positive membership result would refute universal #257; no such producer is proved.
  • remaining_open.universal_257_all_infinite_supports — Prove irrationality for every infinite support A, not only the named support families formalised here.
  • remaining_open.erdos_269_three_prime_irrationality — Determine irrationality of the running-LCM reciprocal sum for finite prime sets of size at least three. For {2,3,5}, the rationality-to-carry bridge is established and cofinal local-window escape remains open.
  • remaining_open.erdos_1041_lemniscate_connection — Independently review whether the 1958 curve-length wording matches the exact Formal Conjectures path-image-length statement, whose negation is now Lean-checked using ani’s explicit degree-seven polynomial. The checked one-dimensional Hausdorff-measure bound settles that formal statement negatively; the reported small-parameter family is not formalised.
  • remaining_open.erdos_1049_irrationality — Determine whether F(t) = ∑_{n≥1} 1/(tⁿ − 1) is irrational for every rational t > 1. Irrationality of F((31/4)^r) for every positive integer r is a Lean-checked Zudilin specialization; the 3/2 approximant with remainder control and the universal assertion remain open.
  • remaining_open.erdos_243_eventual_recurrence — Prove the Erdős #243 assertion: if 1 ≤ a₁ < a₂ < ··· has aₙ/aₙ₋₁² → 1 and rational reciprocal sum, then aₙ = aₙ₋₁² − aₙ₋₁ + 1 eventually; the checked barrier does not settle the mixed-sign unbounded regime.
  • remaining_open.erdos_269_reduced_tail_nonintegrality — Prove that B·T_a ∉ ℤ for every B ≥ 1 coprime to 30 and every a ≥ 1.
  • remaining_open.erdos_269_cofinal_local_window_escape — Prove that for every B ≥ 1 coprime to 30 and every a₀ ≥ 1 there are ℓ ≥ a₀ and h ≥ 1 with lpr_{W(ℓ,h)}(−B·F(ℓ,h)) > K(B, ℓ+h), where K is the defined long-paper cap.
  • remaining_open.erdos_269_two_dimensional_representation — Transcendence of D_{2,3,5}, which is irrational: represent it faithfully by a specified two-dimensional Mahler-type value theorem with every hypothesis verified, give a conditional theorem under explicit logarithmic nondegeneracy, or prove no such representation exists.
  • remaining_open.erdos_243_overlap_height_growth — Decide whether every nonterminal canonical orbit of the reduced-orbit problem has limsup_n (log M_n)/n > 0, equivalently 2^n ≤ M_n^K infinitely often for some K ≥ 1.
  • remaining_open.erdos_249_first_harmonic_anti_concentration — Decide whether, for each h ≥ 1, some s ≥ 1 and 0 < η < 1 give, for every X₀, admissible X and L meeting the displayed size conditions for which the four first-harmonic bounds hold.
  • remaining_open.twenty_one_scaled_remainder_cofinal_return — Decide whether the scaled actual greedy remainder returns cofinally to one bounded interval: whether some B < ∞ has 2^N r_N ≤ B at arbitrarily large N.
  • remaining_open.twenty_one_actual_orbit_invariant — Decide whether a bounded-memory 2-adic or discrepancy invariant of the actual support forces a closed return or forbids permanent supercapacity, or prove no such invariant exists.
  • remaining_open.twenty_one_final_skip_exclusion — Decide whether the final-skip signatures prove |E − a_M| ≥ gap_M, contradicting 0 < a_M − E < gap_M, for E = ∑_{n≥1}(2^n − 1)^{−1} and the last-skip approximant a_M.

Mathematical programmes

  • erdos257_half_story — Achievement-set geometry and the rational-target seams. Exact geometry and reductions for the 1/2 and 1/21 branches; neither target membership nor universal Erdős #257 is proved.
  • erdos249_certificate_story — #249 certificate and harmonic interface. The certificate formulation is exact and finite instances are checked; the unbounded certificate supply and irrationality of S remain open.
  • structured_support_families — Classical and structured support irrationality. These are structured families, coefficient classes, and a conditional bouquet reduction; arbitrary infinite supports in universal Erdős #257 remain open.
  • erdos249_diagonal_arithmetic — #249 diagonal arithmetic and fresh-loss interfaces. Each interface sharpens or re-expresses the same supply problem; no unbounded avoidance, slack, or separated-projection supply is proved.
  • boolean_mobius_constraints — Boolean Möbius carry and global rationality constraints. These are exact characterisations and necessary consequences of rationality; they do not contradict every hypothetical rational value or settle universal Erdős #257.
  • transport_curvature_programme — Transport, curvature, phase separation, and no-go results. The actual-LCM frontier, corridor, consumers, and countermodels are exact, but no cofinal curvature, transport, phase-separation, or anti-reconstruction producer is proved.
  • lambert_obstruction_interfaces — Mersenne–Lambert identities and obstruction interfaces. These are exact identities, obstruction theorems, and one conditional rank consequence; they do not form an irrationality criterion for S.
  • probabilistic_gcd_geometry — Coprimality probability, gcd moments, and Stern–Brocot geometry. Exact identities, denominator transfer, convergence, and combinatorial stability only; no irrationality or novelty claim.
  • half_carry_compactness_programme — Half-carry compactness, windows, seams, and finite propagation. The closure implications, local propagation laws, and bounded stages are exact; no cofinal or coherent unbounded window family is proved, so neither half-membership nor universal Erdős #257 follows.
  • arithmetic_obstruction_interfaces — Denominator, CRT, moment, and gauge obstructions. These are exact arithmetic interfaces, finite mechanisms, and obstruction theorems; they do not supply an unbounded certificate family or an irrationality criterion for the totient constant.

Where the substance is

The working records end at “The wall”; the mathematics paper ends with “What we need from a mathematician”; docs/RESULTS.md opens with a ten-minute verdict.

Scale

Navigation inventory, not results. Generated certificate shards are counted as formal source, never as separate mathematical claims. The two roots currently expose 1,903 modules and 164,639 declarations across #68, #243, #249, #251, #257, #269, #1041, and #1049; exact counts and atlas handles remain in docs/orientation.json.

The exhaustive declaration and import index is docs/declaration_atlas.json.

Mathematical programme routes

Programme routes are bounded handles, not extra claims; their exact focus and claim ceiling are returned by the canonical route packet.

Open one programme with python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --route <programme_route_id>. The packet returns the ordered claim handles, exact open boundary, related programmes, and source owners without loading the exhaustive graph.

Problem and family routes

Each of the eight public problem routes returns every reviewed result family, exact Lean declaration/source handles where supplied, the paper record, and exact open obligations: python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --route erdos_<problem_number>. For a dedicated paper’s anchor census use python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --paper-source <paper_source>, then follow each exact --paper-anchor handle. The machine descriptor’s selection surface separates the authored flagship spine, gateway cohort, and lower-signal disposition list; review-matrix order is only stable drilldown order, never a significance proxy.

Selection spine and long tail

The descriptor exposes the authored flagship spine, broader gateway cohort, and lower-signal dispositions with their reasons and open obligations.

Flagship families: 7; gateway cohort: 15; lower-signal families: 23; these are visibility tiers, not significance rankings. Use python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --publication-architecture for the selection decisions and --publication-family <family_id> for each full reason, source route, open obligation, and Comparator disposition.

Principal claim routes

Principal claim handles are preserved in docs/orientation.json; exact statements and all declarations remain in docs/claims.json. Query a claim with python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --claim <claim_id>. A conditional reduction or finite instance does not settle its open proposition; the ranked families above are the first signal, not a replacement for the exact claim registry.

Read by intent

Use python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --route <route_id>. All route ids, titles, and reading lists are in docs/orientation.json.

Drill down

External corpus registration

docs/corpus_descriptor.json uses schema erdos249257-corpus-descriptor/5. The release gate keeps it below 64 KB. It carries release identities, content digests, principal claim and declaration handles, and the root module topology. Complete claims, module imports, declaration prose, methodology, both authored papers, and the paper-to-Lean source-sigil crosswalk remain in their digest-bound expansion files. These authored surfaces remain distinct from Lean proof authority.

Query one handle

The read-only query helper returns bounded JSON and typed drilldown handles: module packets expose import neighbours, claim packets expose typed edges and open-proposition packets preserve the unresolved target and its progress. Paper labels resolve to exact TeX lines; declaration packets add pinned Lean URLs, module context, and attached claims.

python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --format card
python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --claim denominator_exclusion
python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --route instant_orientation
python3 scripts/query_corpus.py --route erdos249_diagonal_arithmetic